Bakeries in Nashville, Indiana for Cakes, Cookies, Bread & More

In Nashville, Indiana and need a cake for a milestone birthday? Or cookies for a retreat welcome bag? Just craving something sweet after a hike? Whether you’re planning a full event or just passing through town, these are the local bakeries and small-batch bakers Brown County locals actually use and recommend.

I’ve hosted a lot of weddings, retreats, and family weekends over the years—both personally, and for our guests at the Brown County Barn Burner—and I bake quite a bit myself, so I tend to notice what people are still talking about after the cake’s been cut. So the list of local bakeries in this post is a mix of firsthand experience, plus trusted recommendations from guests, friends, and local Facebook groups.

You’ll find custom cake-makers, gluten-free bakers, last-minute sheet cakes, decorated cookies, and seasonal farmstand pies, all organized by use case, so you can find what fits your vibe (and timeline). You can keep scrolling to check out all the options, or click below to jump straight to the section you’re looking for:

• Custom Cakes for Weddings, Birthdays & Big Events
• Decorated Cookies, Cupcakes & Fun Bakes for Parties
• Local Bakeries with Other Fresh-Baked Treats
• Farmstand Bakers & Cottage-Style Goodies

Custom Cakes for Weddings, Birthdays & Big Events

If you’re planning a wedding, milestone birthday, or anything that deserves its special cake, Brown County has several talented bakers who specialize in custom orders. Some offer tiered cakes, some specialize in meeting dietary needs, and a few are available only by pre-order or for specific events, so plan ahead if you’ve got your heart set on something specific.

Here are the bakers I’ve personally used or regularly see recommended:

Offbeet Bakery

This is hands-down the best all-around bakery in town. It’s the only full-service brick-and-mortar option in Nashville, and I’ve used them for more events than I can count.

Gorgeous cakes, incredible flavors, plus amazing gluten-free and vegan options. If you plan to contact only one bakery, start here.

OFFBEET BAKERY | Website | Facebook | Instagram | 📍 37 Mound St |

Icing on the Cake by Kristina

Kristina recently moved from Nashville to Columbus, but she’s still a favorite in local groups, especially for stunning wedding cakes. Her cakes are absolutely beautiful, and she’s known for clean lines, florals, and elegant finishes.

ICING ON THE CAKE BY KRISTINA | Website | Facebook |

Burgess Bakehouse

Everything here is gluten-free, and many items are also vegan or allergy-friendly. A great option if you’ve got guests with dietary restrictions, or just want something different. Burgess Bakehouse takes pre-orders, or you can sometimes stock up from their farmstand.

BURGESS BAKEHOUSE | Website | Facebook | Instagram | 📍 8714-8730 N Old Haggard Rd |

Johnny’s Grub to Go

You might know Johnny’s for its food trailer serving Filipino-American specialties, but owner Ginger is also incredibly talented at custom cakes. Ginger’s ube cake has a serious local following, but she’s happy to create all kinds of styles and flavors, and you’ll often see her recommended in local Facebook groups for anyone looking for a special cake.

JOHNNY’S GRUB TO GO | Facebook | Instagram | 📍 3982 SR 46 W |

Take the Cake

A farmers market regular and pop-up vendor. Shelley makes delicious cakes in fun flavors and beautiful designs. You’ll need to pre-order, but she’s a solid local pick.

TAKE THE CAKE | Facebook |

Brown County IGA

Not fancy, but reliable. They offer grocery-store-style sheet cakes, cupcakes, and custom orders, great for last-minute needs or casual celebrations.

BROWN COUNTY IGA | Website | Facebook | 📍 30 Hawthorne Dr |

Other Local Bakeries for Cakes

These are names I haven’t personally used (because honestly, how many custom cakes does one person need?), but they come up often in local community Facebook groups and event planning threads when people are asking for recommendations:

• Home Baked Happiness – Reyana Marchuk
• Sweet Eats
• The Sweet Spot
• Hilo Girl Bakery
• Lolly’s Pops
• Vivian Bakes

Decorated Cookies, Cupcakes & Fun Bakes for Parties

If you’re planning a kids’ party, welcome gift basket, retreat snack table, or just want something playful and custom, these local bakers specialize in treats that look as good as they taste. Many of them create hand-decorated cookies, themed cupcakes, or custom boxes you can pre-order for your event.

Here are the ones I’ve either worked with directly or see regularly recommended in local groups:

Offbeet Bakery

In addition to custom cakes, Offbeet also makes beautifully decorated sugar cookies (including gluten-free options) and cupcakes. Their designs are always fun but polished, and they’re a solid go-to for most event needs.

OFFBEET BAKERY | Website | Facebook | Instagram | 📍 37 Mound St |

Artistry Cookie Co

The name fits. Her cookies are actual works of art. I’ve worked with her many times for events and retreats, and people always comment on how incredible they look (and taste).

ARTISTRY COOKIE CO | Website | Facebook | Instagram |

Other Local Bakeries for Cookies & Cupcakes

These are others I haven’t personally used, but they’ve been recommended often enough that they’re worth looking into:

• Cupcake Cart – Custom cakes and cupcakes; great local reputation.
• Cupcake Couture – Also offers both cakes and cupcakes.
• Sugar Bayer’s Cookies – Beautifully decorated and well-reviewed locally.
• The Blonde Bakery – Consistently shows up in local recs, especially for cupcakes.

These bakers often book up quickly for holidays and weekends, so if you’re planning a themed order, get in touch early.

Local Bakeries with Other Fresh-Baked Treats

Not every event calls for a custom cake. Sometimes you just want a pie for the cabin, cookies for a group hike, or something sweet to leave out for guests. These local spots offer fresh-baked goods that are easy to grab (and still make you look like you planned ahead).

Offbeet Bakery

Still the best all-around option. It’s a full bakery with a rotating case of cookies, bread, scones, seasonal treats, and more. I stop here often, and I’ve never been disappointed.

OFFBEET BAKERY | Website | Facebook | Instagram |📍37 Mound St |

Nashville General Store & Bakery

A great option in the heart of town. You’ll find classic baked goods with an old-school feel, like sweet breads, muffins, cinnamon rolls, cookies, and more.

NASHVILLE GENERAL STORE | Facebook |📍118 E Washington St |

The Daily Grind

A coffee shop with a surprisingly strong bakery case. Stocked fresh daily with muffins, pastries, and cookies. A solid stop for breakfast treats or snacky desserts.

THE DAILY GRIND | Website | Facebook | Instagram |📍 114 S Van Buren St |

Brownie’s Bean Blossom Family Restaurant

Known for their homemade pies. You can usually get slices on-site, but they also take pre-orders for whole pies if you’re planning ahead.

BROWNIE’S BEAN BLOSSOM | Website | Facebook |📍5730 SR 135 N |

Brown County IGA

Not especially glamorous, but incredibly useful. They’ve got sheet cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and other standard grocery-store baked goods. Especially helpful if you forgot to pre-order or need something same-day.

BROWN COUNTY IGA | Website | Facebook | 📍 30 Hawthorne Dr |

👉 If you’re looking specifically for donuts or cinnamon rolls, check out my full post here.

Farmstand Bakers & Cottage-Style Goodies

Some of the best baked goods in Brown County come from home kitchens, farmstands, and market tables.

These small-batch bakers often post availability on Facebook or offer pre-orders for cakes, sweet breads, cookies, and pies. Many are seasonal, so timing and pickup logistics vary, but they’re worth tracking down.

These are the names I see most often, either through local markets or direct recommendations:

• Bean Blossom Baking Company – Market vendor and pop-up baker offering everything from cakes to cookies. Known for quality and creative flavors.
• Baked by Brandee – A small farmstand operation with a growing local following. Think sweet breads, pies, and rotating baked goods.
• Little Brown County Bakery – Cottage-style operation with classic desserts and homestyle baked goods.
• Brown County Homegrown – Focused on fresh, local goods, which often includes baked treats alongside produce and pantry items.
• Little Red Farmhouse Hobby Farm – Check their social for availability; often has fresh-baked bread and other treats.
• Blue Cottage Homestead – Seasonal farmstand with fresh-baked options. Worth a stop if you’re driving nearby or following along on social.
• Happy Haven LLC – Typically pre-orders only, but they offer baked goods that work well for small events or weekend gatherings.
• WannaBees Bakery & Farmstand, LLC – Another farmstand favorite. Known for sweet rolls, breads, and generous portions.

Some of these bakers offer porch pickup or stand-alone farmstands stocked with goodies, while others require direct contact and advance orders.

Looking for Donuts or Cinnamon Rolls in Nashville, Indiana?

If your idea of a perfect morning includes a warm cinnamon roll or a fresh-baked donut with all the toppings, you’ve got a few great options around town, plus even more at seasonal farmstands.

Here are a few favorites worth seeking out:

• Volants at Olde Bartley House – Croissant-style pastries (called Volants) that are flaky, buttery, and absolutely worth the detour.
• Ooey Gooey Cinnamon Rolls – Huge, soft cinnamon rolls that live up to the name. A crowd favorite for cabin weekends or brunch spreads.
• Percy’s Perk – Known for their ‘Design-A-Donut’ bar, where you pick your toppings. Great stop with kids or for a fun breakfast treat.
• Nashville BP – Yes, really. The gas station bakes donuts fresh daily. Nothing fancy, just the classics done right. It’s also a solid option for breakfast sandwiches and last-minute snacks.

👉 For the full list of local spots selling fresh-baked donuts and cinnamon rolls, check out the full post here.

Sweeten Your Weekend or Celebration with Treats from a Local Bakery

Whether you’re planning a wedding, surprising someone with a birthday cake, or just grabbing pastries for the porch, there’s no shortage of local talent baking right here in Brown County.

From decorated cookies and custom cakes to last-minute grocery store solutions, you’ve got options, and most of them are small businesses that genuinely care about making your event feel special.

If you’re still piecing together your plans, these posts can help you round things out:

• Catering in Nashville, Indiana for Weddings, Retreats & Events
• Donuts & Cinnamon Rolls in Brown County
• Brown County Retreat & Wedding Planning Info