Bed and Breakfasts in Nashville, Indiana & Brown County (2024)
Tanglewood Hideaway partners with different affiliate platforms to generate commissions. When you click on a link and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. It’s just one way you can support my small business. I am also a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and may earn from qualifying purchases made there. You can see my Privacy Policy for more information.
Looking for the perfect bed and breakfast in Nashville, Indiana? Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway or just want a cozy place to stay while exploring Brown County, finding the right B&B can make all the difference. But here’s the thing—while Nashville is known for its charming, small-town vibe, traditional bed and breakfasts are surprisingly hard to come by.
In this post, I’ll guide you through the best options for bed and breakfasts in Nashville, Indiana, from the true B&Bs that offer a homey, personalized experience to boutique inns and hotels that also provide a complimentary breakfast. As someone who lives here, owns an Airbnb of my own, and stays up-to-date with the local lodging scene, I’ve seen a lot of changes over the years. Many places that once operated as bed and breakfasts have either closed or shifted to a different model, making it tough to find accurate, current information online.
That’s why I’ve put together this list to help you find the best options available today—without the guesswork. Let’s dive into the bed and breakfasts that still deliver the experience you’re looking for in Brown County:
#1 Top Pick
The Robinwood Inn offers a cozy and private experience with the convenience of being just a short drive from downtown Nashville and Brown County State Park.
Each cabin is thoughtfully decorated and comes equipped with everything you need for a comfortable stay, including a private hot tub, fireplace, and kitchen. Breakfast for guests is provided at the Bird’s Nest Cafe, which is one of my favorite restaurants in Brown County.
For those traveling with pets, two of the cabins allow pets, and you might even see some of the inn’s resident animals during your stay. The lack of shared common areas means you’ll have plenty of privacy, and each cabin has its own entrance and outdoor space.
If you want a place where you can relax, take it easy, and enjoy some quiet time, Robinwood Inn is a top pick. It’s close to the action but feels miles away from the hustle and bustle—perfect for recharging after a day of exploring.
- Amenities: Breakfast Provided, Private Hot Tub, Fireplace, Pet-Friendly, Wi-Fi
- Best for: Couples, small groups, or anyone who values privacy and wants a comfortable stay near Nashville and Brown County State Park.
#2 Pick
Just 3.5 miles from downtown Nashville, the 1875 Homestead Bed and Breakfast is a perfect spot if you want to enjoy Brown County’s charm with a bit of seclusion. This B&B, set on five quiet acres, is housed in a beautifully restored Victorian home from the late 1800s, blending historic details with modern comforts. Each room is individually decorated with antique touches and cozy features like private baths, luxury bedding, and some with fireplaces or two-person Jacuzzis.
Mornings here start with a hearty, home-cooked breakfast served in The Gathering Room on antique dishes—it’s the kind of meal that sets you up for a day of exploring. Whether you spend your day hiking in Brown County State Park or browsing the shops in Nashville, you’ll love coming back to the comfort of the Homestead. Evenings can be spent relaxing in one of the inviting common areas or enjoying complimentary soft drinks and homemade cookies.
If you’re looking for a place that combines history with comfort and gives you a real taste of Brown County, 1875 Homestead is a solid choice. It’s close enough to everything, but far enough away to let you really unwind.
- Amenities: Breakfast Provided, Fireplace, Jacuzzi in Room, Wi-Fi
- Best for: Couples or solo travelers looking for a peaceful, romantic stay with a touch of history.
#3 Pick
Located halfway between Nashville and Bloomington, the Slippery Elm Shoot Inn offers a peaceful escape in the heart of Brown County. This colonial farmhouse, set on 80 acres, is a hidden gem for those wanting to unwind and enjoy a slower pace. The inn features three uniquely decorated rooms, each with its own private bath and a story to tell—whether it’s filled with family heirlooms, military memorabilia, or a nod to Scottish and Irish heritage.
Mornings here start with a full English breakfast, including fresh-baked pastries and breakfast breads, served in a cozy, antique-filled dining room. Whether you’re exploring nearby Yellowwood State Forest or just taking a leisurely stroll through the garden, the Slippery Elm Shoot Inn is a place where you can truly relax.
If you’re planning a crafting retreat or just need a weekend getaway, this inn offers the space and tranquility you’re looking for. With its unique blend of history, comfort, and nature, Slippery Elm Shoot Inn is a great choice for anyone seeking a quiet retreat.
- Amenities: Breakfast Provided, Wi-Fi
- Best for: Travelers looking for a quiet, countryside retreat with a touch of history and a love for nature.
#4 Pick
The Red Rabbit Inn is a cozy cabin that sits in a peaceful, secluded setting between Nashville and Bloomington. With a loft bedroom, full kitchen, and a private deck overlooking a wooded pond, this cabin is probably the least typical “bed and breakfast” on the list, but it still meets the requirements to be included here. The cabin is perfect for couples looking to relax and recharge, whether you’re enjoying the gas fireplace, soaking in the outdoor hot tub, or grilling dinner on your private deck.
Breakfast is provided and ready in your cabin when you check in, so you can start your mornings at your own pace. The cabin is thoughtfully decorated with works from local artisans, giving it a unique and personal touch. The private hot tub and fire pit area are just for you—no shared spaces here—making it a true escape from the everyday.
If you’re looking for a place that’s close to outdoor adventures, shopping, and local attractions, but still offers complete privacy and comfort, the Red Rabbit Inn is an ideal choice.
- Amenities: Breakfast Provided, Private Hot Tub, Fireplace, Wi-Fi, Full Kitchen
- Best for: Couples seeking a private, romantic escape with modern amenities, close to both Bloomington and Nashville.
#5 Pick
The Lil Black Bear Inn is a quaint seven-room bed and breakfast located on State Road 46, just a short drive from downtown Nashville. This inn offers a relaxed, homey atmosphere with custom furnishings, local artwork, and warm hospitality from the owners.
Each morning, you’ll wake up to a country-style breakfast, complete with gourmet coffee and freshly baked goods. If you’re in the mood to relax, the shared six-person hot tub is open to all guests, or you can unwind in one of the rooms with a private whirlpool spa bath. The inn is also pet-friendly, making it a great choice if you’re traveling with your furry friends.
The Lil Black Bear Inn is inspired by the charm of Brown County and a love for the community, which shows in the thoughtful details of each room and the personalized service. If you’re looking for a simple, comfortable stay with a personal touch, this inn is a great option
- Amenities: Breakfast Provided, Shared Hot Tub, Jacuzzis in Some Rooms, Pet-Friendly, Wi-Fi
- Best for: Couples and small families looking for a cozy, pet-friendly stay with personalized hospitality.
Nashville, Indiana Hotels that Provide Breakfast
A complimentary breakfast isn’t as common as you might think in Brown County. In fact, several places that used to offer breakfast, like the Cornerstone Inn and Artists Colony Inn, no longer do. However, there are still a couple of spots where you can start your day with a meal included in your stay:
Quality Inn Nashville
The Quality Inn in Nashville is the only chain hotel in Brown County and one of the few hotels that still provides a complimentary breakfast. It’s a solid choice if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option with the convenience of breakfast before heading out to explore. You can read more about the Quality Inn Nashville in my post about the best hotels in Nashville, Indiana.
Story Inn
Located in Southern Brown County in the historic village of Story, the Story Inn offers a complimentary breakfast with your stay in their charming, rustic rooms. It’s a unique experience, blending history with hospitality, and breakfast here is a perfect way to begin a day of adventure in Brown County. You can read more about the Story Inn in my post about the best hotels in Nashville, Indiana.
Aren’t There Other Bed and Breakfasts in Nashville, Indiana?
If you’ve been searching for a place to stay in Brown County, you might have come across some “bed and breakfasts” that aren’t listed here. And there’s a good reason for that—there just aren’t many true bed and breakfasts left in the area!
When I think of a B&B, I picture a small lodging establishment or a private family home with just a few rooms for rent, offering a cozy breakfast each morning. While we do have a few of those, as listed above, the options are pretty limited.
However, you’ll also find several small, boutique hotels or inns in Brown County that include a complimentary breakfast, so I’ve added those to this list above too. They might not fit the traditional B&B mold, but they still offer a similar vibe with the convenience of breakfast included.
But What About Those Other “B&Bs” You’ve Seen Listed?
The lodging scene in Brown County has changed a lot in recent years, thanks to both general shifts in the local economy and changes in ownership.
As someone who lives here, owns an Airbnb, and closely follows these changes, it’s both amusing and frustrating to see outdated lists online that include “bed and breakfasts” that no longer fit the bill—some have closed, others have stopped serving breakfast, and a few aren’t even in Brown County!
To clear up the confusion, here’s a rundown of some places you might have seen listed elsewhere that aren’t actually bed and breakfasts anymore:
- No Longer Serve Breakfast
- Artists Colony Inn: While this was once a popular B&B, it no longer serves breakfast.
- Cornerstone Inn: Another place that used to serve breakfast but no longer does.
- The Allison House Inn: No longer a traditional B&B. It’s now a whole-house rental through Airbnb, so you can only rent the entire space for a large group.
- Olde Magnolia House: Similar to The Allison House Inn, this property has transitioned to a whole-house Airbnb rental.
- Never Served Breakfast (To My Knowledge)
- The Yellowwood Inn: This inn doesn’t serve breakfast, despite what you might read elsewhere.
- Grand Wood Suites: This is actually a hotel, not a B&B. You can rent individual rooms or suites, but breakfast isn’t included.
- Green Valley Lodge: No breakfast offered here.
- Closed Permanently
- Oakhaven B&B: Sold and closed years ago.
- Orchard Hill Inn: Currently owned by Quaff On! Brewing Company, it’s used for storage and office space. It hasn’t operated as an inn since before 2016.
- Red Bud Inn: Converted to climate-controlled self-storage units. It hasn’t operated as an inn since before 2020.
And then there are some listings on the Brown County Visitor’s Center website that are just regular Airbnbs. While they’re available to book, they don’t offer breakfast and have never operated as traditional B&Bs:
- 1078 Hideaway
- 1906 Helmsburg Station
- Betty Lou’s Garden
- Ferguson House Suites
- Fire and Rainfall Rooms
- Girlfriend Getaway Suite
- Harmony Tree Resorts
- Iris Garden Downtown Cottages & Suites
- The Hideaway on Redbud Lane
- The Historic Doc Tilton House
- The Loft by Moondance
So, if you’re seeing these names pop up in your search for a B&B, now you know why they’re not on my list! I do my best to keep this information updated, but as things continue to change in Brown County, there may always be a slight lag.
Remember, the options I’ve included here are either true bed and breakfasts or places that still offer a delicious breakfast as part of your stay. If breakfast is a priority for you, these are your best bets in the area.
Wrap-Up: Bed and Breakfasts in Nashville, Indiana
Finding the perfect bed and breakfast in Nashville, Indiana, doesn’t have to be a challenge. Whether you’re drawn to the charm of a traditional B&B or the convenience of a boutique inn that still offers breakfast, there are some excellent options here that will make your stay memorable.
But keep in mind, the lodging landscape in Brown County has changed a lot over the years. Some places you might see listed as B&Bs on other websites no longer operate as such, so it’s crucial to know what to expect before you book. I’ve done my best to keep this guide up-to-date, ensuring that the places I’ve listed still offer that classic bed and breakfast experience—or at least, a delicious breakfast to start your day.
If you’re ready to book your stay, don’t wait too long! The most popular spots fill up quickly, especially during peak seasons like fall. Whether you’re planning a romantic weekend or just need a cozy place to unwind after exploring Brown County, I hope this guide helps you find the perfect fit.
Now that you’ve sorted out your accommodations, it’s time to plan the rest of your trip. Whether you’re exploring the trails in Brown County State Park, visiting local shops and galleries, or enjoying live music at the Brown County Music Center, there’s plenty to see and do.
Enjoy your stay in Brown County! And don’t forget to check out my guides to the best restaurants and shops in the area to make the most of your visit.
