10 Best Brown County & Nashville, Indiana Hotels (2024)

My Top 5 Picks: Best Hotels in Brown County & Nashville, Indiana

10 Best Hotels in Nashville, Indiana

The Cornerstone Inn has been a favorite in Brown County for over 27 years. Located right in downtown Nashville, it’s a short walk to shopping, dining, art, and entertainment. 

The inn features 41 different accommodations, including luxury cottage suites, guest rooms, a two-bedroom tourist home, and a studio apartment. Most options are suite or cottage style and include a kitchenette, which is perfect for longer stays. Balconies, whirlpool tubs, and fireplaces add to the cozy vibe.

I don’t typically book hotels while traveling (I prefer Airbnbs), but if I needed to book one in Nashville then the Cornerstone Inn would check almost all of my boxes.  They no longer serve breakfast, but there are plenty of restaurant options nearby, or you could easily store easy breakfast items in the fridge in your room.

The Brown County Inn is a great choice for anyone wanting a comfortable stay with plenty of amenities. Located just three blocks from downtown Nashville, it offers 99 guest rooms, including two suites. The rooms have been recently updated with new furniture, carpet, paint, beds, and more.

Families will love the year-round indoor/outdoor pool, mini golf course, playground, and on-site restaurant. The inn sits on 10 acres of walkable gardens, providing a beautiful setting for your stay. The Salt Creek Trail offers a safe and scenic route for walking into town and enjoying nature.

The inn is also perfect for larger groups with its conference and banquet facilities that can accommodate up to 200 guests. Whether you’re planning a wedding, a corporate event, or a family reunion, the inn has the space and services you need.

Iris Garden Cottages & Suites is a charming and cozy lodging option right in the heart of downtown Nashville. With a variety of rooms, including suites and cottages, this property offers a comfortable and convenient stay for any number of guests. The location is unbeatable – you step out of your door and you’re among the shops, theaters, and restaurants.

Each unit features a seating area with a TV, satellite channels, a microwave, a fridge, and a coffee machine. Some units even have decks and grills, perfect for relaxing outdoors. There’s plenty of parking, a bike washing station, and laundry facilities in some units, making it an ideal spot for longer stays or active visitors.

The friendly owners make you feel like family, adding a personal touch to your stay. For families, the on-site “Copperhead Creek Gem Mine” offers fun for kids and adults alike. Plus, you can grab a bite at Trolly’s BBQ and enjoy the outdoor seating area with a propane fire pit.

The combination of location, amenities, and friendly service makes this a top pick for anyone visiting Nashville.

The Salt Creek Golf Retreat offers a unique lodging experience with its condominium-style accommodations. Located right on one of Indiana’s best golf courses, it’s a must-stay for golf enthusiasts. The condos are spacious, featuring two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a full kitchen, living and dining areas, and a deck or patio with stunning views of the golf course, right next door to the Brown County State Park.

The retreat also boasts a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a full-service restaurant, and the 19th Hole Sports Bar, which offers live music and late-night dining on weekends. It’s the perfect spot to unwind after a day on the greens or exploring the nearby trails.

These condos feel more like a home away from home, offering all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay. Each unit includes a washer and dryer, and the property provides secure bike storage and bike-washing facilities, making it a great choice for mountain bikers. There’s even a discount for guests attending shows at the nearby Brown County Music Center.

The retreat is also an excellent venue for conferences, meetings, retreats, and weddings. The indoor facilities, outdoor deck, and scenic views provide a beautiful backdrop for any event.

These are more like condos than a standard hotel, but the pool, on-site restaurant, and staff mean you’ll have everything and more that you could expect from a hotel. For a relaxing and enjoyable stay in Brown County, Salt Creek Golf Retreat offers the perfect mix of comfort and convenience.

The Story Inn is truly a step back in time. Located about 20 minutes outside of Nashville, it offers a unique experience in a quaint village founded in 1851. The entire town has been turned into The Story Inn, featuring 14 beautifully renovated rooms and cottages, a gourmet restaurant, and a resident ghost known as the “Blue Lady.”

Each room and cottage at the Story Inn is decorated with Victorian-era furniture and antiques, offering a tranquil disconnect with no TVs, radios, or phones (although they do now have WiFi). The accommodations range from rooms above the historic General Store to various charming cottages. The Story Inn is pet-friendly and even offers horse stalls for equine guests.

The on-site restaurant is a standout, serving refined Hoosier cuisine with seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. The inn also hosts live music, monthly comedy shows, karaoke, and game nights in the Tavern, providing plenty of entertainment options.

If you want a true Brown County experience during your visit – a step back in time, somewhere in the middle of nowhere – then the Story Inn is the hotel to choose. The historic ambiance, combined with modern amenities like dedicated electric car chargers, makes it a unique destination. The haunted history, especially the Blue Lady Room, adds an intriguing touch for those interested in the paranormal.

For a getaway that combines history, charm, and a bit of mystery, the Story Inn is the perfect choice.

The Artists Colony Inn & Restaurant is a charming boutique hotel right in the heart of downtown Nashville. With 20 guest rooms and three suites featuring whirlpool tubs, it offers a blend of historic charm and modern amenities. The on-site restaurant serves up American fare and guests can enjoy a complimentary breakfast each morning.

Located just steps from local shops, cafes, and entertainment, the inn provides the perfect base for exploring Nashville. The antique decor pays homage to Brown County’s artistic heritage, creating a cozy and nostalgic atmosphere.

The inn’s banquet and meeting facilities make it a great venue for retreats, celebrations, and corporate events. With a welcoming ambiance and convenient location, it’s ideal for any occasion.

Recently purchased by new owners, the Artists Colony Inn has plenty of potential changes and improvements on the horizon. While they may not have had time to implement many changes yet, it’s clear the new owners have lots of ideas in the works.

Formerly known as Hidden Valley Inn, Grand Wood Suites offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Each suite features a private bedroom with a king-size bed, a living area with a queen-size sofa sleeper, a fully-equipped kitchenette, and a private bathroom. Some rooms even have a balcony with city views.

The location is fantastic, just a minute’s walk from downtown Nashville’s shops and restaurants. Despite being close to all the action, it’s tucked away enough to provide the solitude you need for a relaxing Brown County getaway.

Rooms are spacious and are designed with comfort in mind. Guests will appreciate the soundproof walls, ensuring a quiet stay, and the easy ground floor access due to the hotel’s unique layout on a small hill.

For those seeking a blend of comfort and convenience, Grand Wood Suites is a perfect destination. Whether you’re exploring the local shops or enjoying a peaceful night in, this hotel has everything you need for a pleasant and memorable stay.

The Seasons Lodge & Conference Center is a popular choice in Brown County due to its amenities and location close to the Brown County Music Center.  

The lodge features 52 guest rooms, many with balconies or patios, providing beautiful views of the wooded hillside. The rooms are comfortable and well-maintained, featuring air conditioning, flat-screen TVs, and daily housekeeping.

Guests appreciate the lodge’s amenities, including an on-site restaurant, Rafters, which was extensively renovated a few years ago and offers delicious dining options. There’s also a conference center, making it a great spot for meetings, events, and celebrations. The property includes common areas, a game room, and an outdoor patio with gas fire pits, creating a welcoming environment for relaxation and socializing.

While the Season’s Lodge is technically located very close to downtown Nashville, I don’t consider this to be an easily walkable location due to the lack of sidewalks from here to town.  However, For those seeking a convenient and comfortable stay with plenty of amenities, Seasons Lodge is an excellent choice.

The Quality Inn Nashville is Brown County’s only chain hotel, offering reliable service and comfortable accommodations right in the heart of Nashville. With a variety of amenities such as a fitness center, indoor heated pool, and hot tub, it’s a great choice for both business trips and family vacations.

The hotel provides free Wi-Fi throughout the property and a complimentary hot breakfast each morning, ensuring a convenient and enjoyable stay. Each room is equipped with a refrigerator and coffee maker, adding to the comfort of your stay.

The hotel also offers a game room and easy access to the scenic Salt Creek Trail, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. The friendly and responsive service at the Quality Inn ensures you get your money’s worth, making it a dependable choice for your stay in Nashville

If you’re looking for a stay that combines rustic charm with modern amenities, the Abe Martin Lodge at Brown County State Park is a fantastic choice. Nestled in the heart of Indiana’s largest state park, this lodge offers a perfect blend of nature and comfort.

They’ve done a lot of work in recent years to update the rooms at the lodge and the cabins. I don’t know if they’re done with everything yet, but I’ve heard great things about what they’ve completed so far. The indoor water park is a GREAT feature, especially for families with kids.

Plus, you can’t beat the access to everything the State Park has to offer – hiking, biking, horseback riding, and more. Whether you’re exploring the trails, climbing the 90-foot fire tower, or visiting the Nature Center, there’s plenty to keep you busy.

Other Hotels in Brown County, Indiana

While the following hotels didn’t make my Top 10 list, they still offer some unique features that may appeal to certain travelers. Here’s a quick rundown:

• Harmony Tree Resorts – If you’re a light sleeper, you might find the restaurant below and the noise between rooms a bit bothersome. However, this location shines for glamping experiences, which I highly recommend if you’re looking for something different.
• Hotel Nashville – This older hotel isn’t as walkable as others on my list, but it’s still a decent option, especially if you’re planning to dine at the Nashville Chop House, which I really enjoy.
• The Yellowwood – Despite a recent name change and remodel, reviews are still mixed. If you’re looking for suites, this could be worth considering, but it’s not at the top of my list unfortunately.
• Green Valley Motor Lodge – I don’t see a lot of cars here when I drive by, which makes me wonder about its popularity, but if you’re looking for a no-frills, budget option, it could be a good option.
• Hickory Shades Motel – Located out in Belmont, this isn’t the most convenient spot if you want to explore all that Brown County has to offer. However, if you’re on a budget, it’s an affordable option, though it’s close to the busy SR 46, which can be noisy.
• Salt Creek Inn – While the location is convenient to town, and especially good if you’re heading to the Brown County Music Center, the lack of cars in the lot and consistently poor reviews are concerning. If you’re on a tight budget, this might be a last resort option, but I’d recommend exploring other choices first.

Frequently Asked Questions About Nashville, Indiana Hotels